top of page

Unmasking Amazon Fake Reviews Epidemic - How to Spot a Fake Review on Amazon & How to Report

Updated: May 10

Amazon Fake Reviews

As online shopping surges, so does the shadowy world of fake reviews, making it imperative for consumers to sharpen their detection skills. Here’s how to spot and steer clear of these deceptive practices. Usually, an actual consumer needs to be very upset and take time from their busy schedule to leave negative feedback unless there is a legitimate reason.

The Deceptive Business of Amazon Fake Reviews - How to Spot a Fake Review on Amazon

Sellers crave positive reviews to boost sales, while reviewers seek rewards or compensation. This symbiotic relationship fuels a thriving underground market for fake reviews. Overseas companies peddle batches of glowing reviews while social media groups mobilize armies of reviewers. Incentives like refunds or freebies persuade genuine buyers to leave favorable

feedback. The allure of monetary gain muddies the waters of authenticity.

Unveiling the Red Flags for Amazon Fake Reviews

Detecting fake reviews requires a discerning eye. Watch for:

  • Overwhelmingly Positive Ratings: A disproportionate number of five-star reviews raise suspicions.

  • Vague Praise: Lack of specific details and generic compliments hint at insincerity.

  • Similar Language: Repeated phrases and generic wording across reviews signal orchestrated efforts.

  • Grammar and Spelling Errors: Poor linguistic quality may indicate hastily crafted fake reviews, usually from a review farm.

  • Inconsistencies: Unrelated products in the "Customers also bought" section or contradictory statements within reviews hint at manipulation.

Deciphering and How To Spot Fake Reviews on Amazon: From 1-Star to 5-Star

Good read below. CNN posted information on how to distinguish between real and fake reviews.

Amazon Fake Reviews

(image from CNN)

Fake 1-star reviews often twist product features listed on the page, parroting the opposite sentiment to undermine credibility. Meanwhile, counterfeit 5-star reviews may sound rehearsed, offering generic assurances like "you won't be disappointed."

Unearthing Amazon reviews and ratings Authenticity While not foolproof, diligent sleuthing can help uncover genuine reviews:

  • Consult External Sources: The internet fundamentals haven't changed for e-commerce brands. An e-commerce website is a must for credibility and customer service. Explore brand websites and YouTube/Social Media channels for comprehensive evaluations. Even if a brand of an overseas seller, factory seller, or foreign agent seller has built a website, check to see if there is an actual way to contact the company via web form, legitimate email address, or phone number. Many of us have seen only an FAQ section and their products, but there is no way to contact them online.

  • Look at the video content - is it well-produced real experiences or how the product performs? Does the brand invest in social media presence, or is it just an overseas factory or agency trying to make money in the USA using Amazon?

  • A fake review usually says the opposite of all or some of the bullet points. For example, suppose a seller sells a memory foam cervical pillow or gel seat cushion. In that case, the fake reviews will say "hard as a rock, bag of rocks" or something so far-fetched that you, the users, need to report it to help protect the integrity of Amazon's platform.

  • Savvy, intelligent buyers will usually check out alternate content, such as YouTube videos, to determine how beneficial the product is and whether it suits them.

  • You might want to dig if they don't have a website but 14,000+ reviews and a best-seller badge on Amazon.

  • There is a benefit to genuine 1-star reviews. For example, if a consumer is looking for a firm mattress or extra firm and reads a lot of 1-3 stars saying it is firm and just a complaint based on preference for a soft mattress, this can help make an informed buying decision. Also, it could be a competitor that sells a soft mattress embellishing "hard as a rock" or trying to bump buyers off a certain product to buy theirs.

Credible brands on Amazon will invest time and money into a brand storefront and can easily be verified as USA-based brands.

Amazon Fake Reviews

(Image from Amazon)

  • Research the Brand: Check the brand's online presence, including official websites and social media profiles, for legitimacy. Many Amazon sellers do not have a website but might appear to be a legit brand on their listing. Also, a brand that sells checks to see if they have a storefront on Amazon. When you click the storefront, it goes to a listing of other related products, and many consider them substandard brands with funky brand names. If the brand on Amazon doesn't have a storefront + Amazon brand registry or website for customer service, BEWARE, even if they have 15,000+ reviews, blends to a 4.3 rating. Most likely, these were compiled before 2021.

  • Review Reviewers: To gauge credibility, examine reviewers' profiles for review count, purchase history, and Amazon's "Impact" score. You will often see them with lots of sporadic products they buy and 5 stars mixed with 1-3 stars. Review farms and overseas fake customers have networks throughout the United States that can flood a listing with fake purchases and returns. If Amazon's AI doesn't flag the fakes, especially on a new, unestablished product, it can ruin that seller's listing. You can search Amazon fake review forums and see what the sellers experience.

The Crackdown on Fake Reviews: Amazon's Battle Against Deception

In response to mounting concerns over fraudulent practices, Amazon has initiated aggressive measures to combat fake reviews. However, the journey towards transparency has been fraught with challenges, including the persistence of established brands leveraging deceptive tactics.

Amazon's Strides Against Deception

Amazon's intensified scrutiny began with concerted efforts to root out fake reviews, marking significant milestones in the fight against deceit:

  • Amazon Crackdown Initiatives (Date): In recent years, Amazon has ramped up its crackdown on fake reviews, deploying advanced algorithms and manpower to identify and remove fraudulent content.

  • FTC Intervention: The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has deemed participation in fake reviews illegal, issuing stern warnings and initiating legal actions against violators. Paying to Sabotage a Rival Seller – FTC Wants to Stop the Practice This article discusses the challenges Amazon sellers face in battling to keep their brand reputations as accurate as possible. Competitors paying commissions to leave fake feedback on Amazon is another issue sellers face. Imagine if these competitors who partake in this practice focused on their brand and game plan. They might actually be able to compete with other brands.

During the hearing, which was open to the public and available via webcast, three interested parties will provide oral statements addressing issues raised during the rulemaking process.

On July 31, 2023, the FTC published a Federal Register notice proposing a new rule to stop marketers from using illicit review and endorsement practices such as using fake reviews, suppressing honest negative reviews, and paying for positive reviews, which deceive consumers looking for real feedback on a product or service and undercut honest businesses.

In response to the proposed rulemaking, three of the 100 commenters requested to present their positions at an informal hearing. They include the Interactive Advertising Bureau, Fake Review Watch, and a group of academic researchers. Time magazine online addresses the war on fake consumer reviews:

How to Spot a Fake Review on Amazon

(photo from Time Magazine website)

The Fallout: Brand Bans and Legal Consequences for Fake Review Manipulation

Despite Amazon's vigilance, certain brands have skirted detection, capitalizing on the pre-crackdown era to amass thousands of fake reviews. However, the tide is turning, with Amazon wielding its ban hammer and the FTC wielding legal repercussions:

  • Brand Bans: Amazon has implemented stringent measures, banning brands caught engaging in fake review schemes, irrespective of their stature.

  • Legal Ramifications: The FTC's crackdown on fake reviews underscores the severity of the issue, threatening legal action against entities found complicit in fraudulent practices.

Report Suspicious Activity: Report instances of fake reviews to Amazon and relevant authorities, contributing to the collective effort to uphold integrity in online commerce. Unveiling Competitive Tactics: The Dark Side of Review Farms In the cutthroat world of e-commerce, rival sellers resort to nefarious tactics, including the utilization of review farms and groups, to gain an unfair advantage on Amazon. Here's a closer look at how these clandestine operations aim to manipulate seller scores, return rates, and organic rankings. The Rise of Review Farms and Groups Driven by the desire to outmaneuver competitors, sellers orchestrate coordinated efforts through review farms and groups: Impact on Seller Metrics and Rankings The exploitation of review farms and groups can have far-reaching consequences, influencing critical seller performance metrics and organic ranking algorithms: Sneaky Amazon Review Tactics: The Insertion of Fake 1-3 Star Reviews In a bid to conceal their deceptive activities, sellers employ subtle tactics, including the insertion of fake 1-3 star reviews: With online shopping booming, the scourge of fake reviews poses a significant challenge for consumers seeking authentic product insights. Here's a comprehensive look at Amazon's efforts to combat this pervasive issue and how savvy shoppers can navigate the landscape of deceit. Amazon's Vigilance Against Fake Reviews Amazon's battle against fake reviews has seen notable milestones, marked by the implementation of stringent measures: Summary: Empowering Consumers in the Fight Against Fake Reviews - How to report a fake review if you spot one While the battle against fake reviews persists, consumers can navigate the deceptive landscape with vigilance and technological assistance. By remaining informed and leveraging available resources, shoppers can safeguard their purchasing decisions and uphold integrity in the online marketplace.

Reporting fake reviews on Amazon is vital in maintaining product feedback's credibility and ensuring a fair marketplace for all users. To report a suspicious review, follow these steps:

  1. Identify the Review: Navigate to the review you believe to be fake on the product page.

  2. Click "Report abuse": Beneath the review, locate the "Report abuse" link and click on it.

  3. Provide Details: Amazon will prompt you to explain why you believe the review is fake. Be specific and provide any evidence or observations that support your claim.

  4. Submit the Report: Once you've provided all necessary information, submit your report to Amazon for review.

  5. Follow Up: Amazon takes these reports seriously and investigates each case thoroughly. While you may not receive immediate feedback, rest assured that your report contributes to maintaining the integrity of reviews on the platform.

By reporting fake reviews, you play an active role in upholding trust and transparency in the Amazon marketplace, ultimately benefiting all users and ensuring a more reliable shopping experience.


bottom of page